Instrumented Interconnecteds Intelligent

By Stephen Baker

Picture the smart, unassuming person at a meeting, who says, “Well, I’m no expert, but once I saw this case where….” That person is doing something that until recently was uniquely human: Soft-pedaling an idea.

Humans beings can soft-pedal because we know what we know (or at least think we do). We also know what we don’t know. And then there’s this entire domain of knowledge in which we know a thing or two. That gray area in the middle is important, because that’s where we can dabble. We can come up with insights and discuss them with people who are better informed. This process widens a discussion beyond the cloistered world of experts. It can lead to insights, the generation of hypotheses, and innovation.

Steve Baker

Steve Baker

One of the very special aspects of Watson, IBM’s Jeopardy computer, is that it “knows” what it doesn’t know–or, more precisely, simulates this knowledge through statistical analysis. Looking beyond Jeopardy, to Watson’s career in business, this gauge of its confidence is one of its most valuable features.

Say Watson is working in a hospital emergency room. A person comes in with a combination of symptoms that no one has seen before. Someone lists them for Watson. (The machine doesn’t have voice-recognition now, but that could be engineered in a matter of days.) Watson scours its base of documents and research papers, finds various combinations of these symptoms, and lists possible diseases or disorders that the person might have. Each one is accompanied by a confidence gauge. It turns out in this case Watson has only 14% confidence in, say, lupus.

That 14% amounts to a big shrug of Watson’s electronic shoulders. It does not know and is admitting as much. And maybe the doctors have done tests and know that it’s not lupus. But maybe below Lupus, with only an 8% confidence rank, is some other disease that they hadn’t considered. It may be wrong. It may be idiotic. But it may also lead to a thought, a connection. After all, that 8% came from some combination of the symptoms that Watson found in its research. In effect, Watson–even in its ignorance–has come up with a list of hypotheses (along with pointers to its sources). If even one of these hypotheses nudges doctors toward a correct diagnosis, the machine has provided a service–even without “knowing” the answer.

When Watson plays Jeopardy on Feb. 14, 15, and 16, many will focus on the machine’s speed and precision on the clues it gets right. But its hidden strength is its knowledge of its own knowledge–including its own limitations. Like us, it’s able to hazard a guess and, equally important, label it as such. That’s one area where Watson stands out.

Stephen Baker is author of Final Jeopardy–Man vs Machine and the Quest to Know Everything.

Bookmark and Share

Previous post

Next post

September 13, 2015
9:47 pm


Posted by: 東リ ホモジニアスビニル床タイルHT 「メルウッド」(6) 180×1260×3.0mm厚 1セ
February 7, 2015
8:36 pm

This blog was… how do you say it? Relevant!!
Finally I have found something that helped me.

homepage (Leonie)

Posted by: Leonie
February 6, 2015
2:20 am

Admiring the time and effort you put into your
site and in depth information you provide. It’s nice to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t
the same unwanted rehashed information. Wonderful read!
I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m including your
RSS feeds to my Google account.

web site (Wally)

Posted by: Wally
July 23, 2012
2:38 am

Very amazing and informative blog. Thanks for creating such a wonderful site. this site was not only knowledgeable but also very stimulating too. Thanks for sharing.

Posted by: Medical Service
2 Trackbacks
February 9, 2011
8:24 pm

[...] search interfaces have continued to use the age old search box for typing keywords as input. While promising work has been done with accepting natural language questions as input, nothing commercially viable has [...]

Posted by: Beyond spam: Big Problems with Search « The Sharer
January 26, 2011
9:31 am

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by IBMResearch, smarterplanet, Steve Hamm, Adriane Leal Filenga, Kevin Winterfield and others. Kevin Winterfield said: RT @smarterplanet: Say #ibmWatson is working in a hospital emergency room and… – [...]

Posted by: Tweets that mention Final Jeopardy Author Steve Baker on Watson: A Smart, Modest Machine | A Smarter Planet Blog --
Post a Comment